What Are Beer Reviews And Ratings

I’m going to look into the popular world of beer reviews and ratings, providing a glimpse into why they’ve become a cornerstone for beer lovers and brewers alike. This isn’t just about tasting notes and point systems; it’s also about the community and culture built around the love for craft beer.

Craft beer has surged in popularity, and with it, the practice of reviewing and rating brews. You’re going to find out about how these discussions do more than guide your next purchase; they shape the industry, influence trends, and encourage the beer community. Each review, whether it’s a quick note on a mobile app or a detailed blog post, contributes to the collective knowledge and appreciation for this art form.

Key components of a trustworthy beer review are not only about the reviewer’s palate but also about their ability to communicate their experience. A credible review will provide context, considering the beer style, the background of the beer and information about the brewery. It’s about respecting the brewer’s intentions while maintaining an honest dialogue with fellow enthusiasts.

Experts play a significant role in beer ratings, but this world isn’t reserved for professionals alone. Beer enthusiasts from all walks of life share their insights, leading to a diverse set of opinions that can help anyone find their next favorite ale or lager. Understanding this dynamic sets the stage for our dive into what makes a beer review truly stand out.

What Makes A Good Beer Review?

Beer Reviews And Ratings

When I write a beer review, there’s a formula I consider. It’s not just about stating whether I like the beer or not; it’s dissecting the experience sip by sip. Let’s break down the essential elements of a beer review that can really resonate with readers.

Appearance might seem superficial when it comes to taste, but we eat and drink with our eyes first. I mention the beer’s colour, clarity, and head retention. Is it a deep amber, a hazy straw colour, or perhaps a deep ruby?

A beer’s aroma sets the stage for what’s to come. It’s the preview that hints at the symphony of flavours about to unfold. A great review captures this essence, describing the scent and noting if it’s hoppy, malty, fruity, or spicy.

Flavour is the heart of a beer review. It’s why we’re all here, after all. I discuss the initial taste, the mid-palate flavors, and the finish. Are there surprises along the way? Does the flavour evolve as it warms?

I try to include mouthfeel as it contributes greatly to a beer’s character. Is it creamy, crisp, light, heavy, or effervescent? Each texture plays its own unique part in the overall beer experience.

But it doesn’t end with just describing what the beer is like. I like to include a little about the story behind the beer. How and where it is brewed. As well as a little background about the brewery.

This context can turn an ordinary review into an immersive experience.

Personal preference will undoubtedly colour any beer review. So I strive for a balance between subjective and objective analysis to help my readers trust my taste. But at the same time decide for themselves based on their preferences.

Navigating this delicate balance is the transition into the world of beer ratings.

In the next section, I’m going to show you how to interpret those ratings. You’re going to find out about the different systems used to categorize and rate beers, what they mean for the consumer, and how you can contribute to the beer rating community.

Mastering the Art of Beer Ratings

In my opinion, navigating beer ratings can sometimes feel like decoding a foreign language. But don’t worry too much about it; I’m here to help you with that.

Every rating system has its peculiarities. For instance, you might see scores out of 100 points, stars out of five, or even caps out of ten.

Personally, I score my beer out of five points.

Social proof shapes a good chunk of the beer industry. When a beer receives high ratings, it’s going to include not just a boost in interest, but often sales too.

This phenomenon isn’t just about the quality of the beer; it’s also about how perception and popularity play into the picture.

Contributing with informed, conscientious ratings can truly enhance the beer community. It’s a way to share your experience that helps fellow enthusiasts make better choices when selecting their next brew.

Remember, though, that your own tasting notes should evolve as your palate develops over time.

I choose something that resonates with me when rating a beer. My approach may differ when reviewing a hoppy beer, as opposed to a stout. In my opinion, it’s crucial to articulate my preferences and experiences without discounting styles I’m less fond of.

A lot is happening very quickly in the world of craft beer, making it more important than ever to help others through my ratings.

I try not to overwhelm new beer enthusiasts with jargon. I like to keep things simple: Is the beer enjoyable? Would I drink it again? Why or why not?

Revisiting a beer and updating my ratings as I gain more knowledge, I think is acceptable. Something I am looking to do going forward.

Flavors that were once unremarkable to me may become fascinating as my tastes mature.

My Beer Reviews

Utilizing Reviews and Ratings to Discover New Favorites

[The video is a slightly controversial beer review from Simon at Real Ale Craft Beer Youtube channel]

I’m here to help you with one of the more delightful challenges you might face: sifting through the massive trove of reviews and ratings to find beers that you’ll love.

In today’s world of endless options, being able to understand what’s out there is a skill in itself.

Some major platforms for beer reviews are RateBeer, BeerAdvocate, and Untappd. These powerhouses offer a wealth of information.

However, they do sometimes leave a lot to be desired. There are some great beer reviews on these sites, but there are also a lot without any content at all.

Many people just give the beers a score without any information like aroma, tasting notes or mouthfeel.

This to me is not helpful, how can anyone make a decision based purely on a number with no reasoning to back it up.

In fact it is this complaint I have seen on several forums that prompted this blog post. Many say that IPA’s are always favoured and get high scores consistently. Whereas lagers very rarely ever score high at all.

I think most people get better information from beer bloggers and video reviews. The information is more comprehensive, covering at the very least appearance, aroma and taste.


I really hope that you use reviews and ratings as a starting point, not an end-all.

Engage with the community, leave your own thoughts, and let others know what you think. It’s not just about following the crowd—it’s about adding your voice to the conversation and helping others navigate this vast sea of choices.

In conclusion, think of beer reviews and ratings as your personal guides, not just tools for decision-making, but as resources for education and community.

With every review you read, and every rating you ponder, you’re stepping deeper into a rich culture brimming with discovery.

It’s time to raise a glass to the continuous learning experience that comes with being a part of the beer lovers community. Cheers!

Don’t forget to engage and leave a comment on your opinion about beer reviews and ratings.

Leave a Comment